Archive for July, 2009

A Times editorial makes the troubling assumption that mustangs are pests that irrevocably damage our public lands.
By Stephanie Boyles
July 31, 2009

The Los Angeles Times’ July 27 editorial “Wild horse sense,” which weighs in on proposals to handle the growing wild  horse population in the western United States, makes at least one good point: Using an immunocontraceptive vaccine (birth control, in other words) developed by the Humane Society of the United States presents the “best hope” for managing wild horses in an effective, humane and cost-beneficial manner. Peer-reviewed studies have shown that by treating more mares with this drug and returning them to the range, rather than detaining them indefinitely in holding centers, the cost of managing wild horses could be reduced by as much as 14% per year, saving taxpayers more than $6 million annually.

An American Icon put at risk by poor management of the BLM

An American Icon put at risk by poor management of the BLM

The Times recommends castrating stallions. This would do little, if anything, to stabilize and reduce wild horse populations on the range over time. It only takes one intact stallion to fertilize an entire harem of fertile mares, so unless you capture and castrate every stallion in a herd, mares who have not been inoculated with the contraceptive will continue to foal.

Worst, The Times appears to come to the indefensible conclusion that wild horses are introduced pests that irrevocably damage our public lands and should therefore be managed by, in addition to castrating stallions, holding the herds in “vast, but contained wildlife refuges.”

Wild horses have been an important part of America’s landscape for centuries, and recent DNA studies have demonstrated that they are, in fact, native wildlife reintroduced to North America more than 400 years ago. In 1971, Congress passed the Wild Free-Roaming Horse and Burro Act, which requires the government to protect America’s mustangs as “living symbols of the historic and pioneer spirit of the West.” The law stipulates that wild horses would be permitted to live free on lands where they existed at the time the act was signed into law.

The notion that horses overpopulate and damage the rangeland is also grossly misleading. A 1990 study by the U.S. General Accountability Office determined that the primary cause of the deterioration of rangeland resources and damaged riparian areas is poorly managed cattle and sheep grazing, which is hardly surprising when you look at the numbers. The Bureau of Land Management oversees about 33,000 wild horses on 34 million acres of land, compared with more than 6 million head of livestock on approximately 160 million acres.The editorial also claims that recent legislation passed by the House, HR 1018 — the Restoring Our American Mustangs (ROAM) Act — would increase the horses’ range by 20 million acres. The Times fails to mention that since the 1971 act was passed, the U.S. Bureau of Land Management has reduced the lands designated for mustangs from 53.5 million acres to 34.3 million acres. The ROAM Act would not increase the horses’ range but simply repatriate those mustangs to the public lands originally designated for them more than 30 years ago. This promising strategy will enable the agency to move horses out of the costly warehousing system and put them back on the range where they belong, saving millions of tax dollars annually.

In addition to reducing on-the-range management costs, the ROAM Act would also reduce off-the-range expenditures by only allowing the BLM to remove animals from the range when demand for horse adoption warrants such an action. It also directs the agency “to implement creative and more aggressive marketing strategies for the adoption program” in order to increase adoption rates and further reduce off-the-range management costs. The Humane Society and other wild horse protection organizations have been active in supporting and organizing the upcoming National Wild Horse Adoption Day events

The proposed ROAM Act would give Americans back their free-roaming horses, swapping a captivity-based approach to wild-horse management for the model Congress originally set forth. The measure would get us back to the basics on mustang management, save taxpayers millions of dollars annually and set our horses free again. Who wouldn’t support that?

Stephanie Boyles is a wildlife scientist with the Humane Society of the United States.


Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

MIAMI-DADE COUNTY (CBS4) — Mutilated, and cut up, the body of another
horse has been found dead along a northwest Miami-Dade road. Miami-Dade
Police say this is the 17th horse butchered in the county since mid-January.

Body of slaughtered horse (click image to view video)

Body of slaughtered horse (click image to view video)

The latest one was slaughtered Sunday at a farm along the 12-thousand
block of NW 157th Street. According to a police report, the horse was
missing chunks of meat on its chest and legs. Police speculate it was
killed for its meat.

Two horses were found slaughtered in a similar way in nearby Miramar
several months ago. Authorities there also believe the horses were
butchered for their meat. Officials believe the meat is being sold on
the black market since the sale of horse meat is illegal in the U.S. No
arrests have been made.

Horse owner Allen Owens, whose horse was previously butchered, is
pleading for the public’s help.

“He was my 4th child. He was my wife’s 4th child. We saw him born,” Owen
told CBS4′s Peter D’Oench.

Owens is haunted by the slaughter of his black and white paint,
“Commanche.” She was just 16 months old.

“For me it’s like what did I ever do to somebody? For them to do this to
me. I had no concept that someone would do this to an animal, for its
meat,” said Owens.

Owens was told he was one of the first owners in Miami-Dade whose horses
have been killed for their meat. He found “Commanche” tied to a post and
horribly mutilated on August 30th of 2007.

“They laid his leg bones up here. 3 legs were missing. His hide was
taken. It was the biggest bloodiest mess I’ve ever seen,” explained Owens.

Horse meat can be sold on the black market for up to $40 a pound.

“They have to be barbarians. They have to be unbelievable people to do
this to an animal,” said Owens. “What he’s done to my family. You never
get past it.”

Owens is speaking out now after a five year old horse was butchered this
past weekend in Northwest Miami-Dade, right in front of her 4-month old
foal. A caretaker burned his body after the discovery.

“Every time I hear about another one, I relive the pain. And it’s
getting worse. It’s time for somebody to do something.”

The SPCA says no one should be buying horse meat. It’s contaminated
because horses often consume all sorts of drugs, de-wormers and antibiotics.

“Whoever is going to buy this meat is going to be sick. You’re paying
$20 to $40 a pound to make yourself sick,” explained SPCA Investigator
Richard Cuoto.

Owens says the black market butchers must be stopped.

“I don’t think any punishment would be strong enough, no punishment
would fit. Commanche loved us. And he loved people,” said Owens.

There are no leads in Commanche’s slaughter.

Blind woman uses tiny horse as guide

Posted: July 28, 2009 by R.T. Fitch in Horse News
Tags: , ,

DEARBORN, Michigan – Mona Ramouni’s fingers fly across the text as she proofreads yet another page of a calculus textbook to be published in Braille — with her guide pony sitting patiently by.

Mona Ramouni plays with her guide horse, Cali in the pen her family built in the yard of their Dearborn, Michigan home. Cali is the first guide animal for Ramouni, 28. – AFP

Mona Ramouni plays with her guide horse, Cali in the pen her family built in the yard of their Dearborn, Michigan home. Cali is the first guide animal for Ramouni, 28. – AFP

It is dull work for tiny Cali who serves as Ramouni’s eyes through a world she cannot see, and the pony keeps butting her head into Ramouni’s chest.

“Cali! Stop it,” Ramouni exclaims, but she can’t keep the pride out of her voice when she realizes what the pretty brown pony with a soft black mane has gotten up to.

Rolling back her thick lips, Cali has grasped the tab of the zipper on the bag of treats Ramouni carries around her waist and is slowly pulling it open with her teeth.

“She knows which part has the carrots,” Ramouni says in amazement. “She’s really smart.”

Cali is just one of a handful of miniature horses in the United States known to be used as guide animals for the blind.

Weighing in at under 100 pounds (45 kilograms) , miniature horses are about the same size as a large dog but are much stockier and can help support people with mobility issues.

They also have significantly longer life spans — they can live and work for more than 30 years while guide dogs are usually retired by age 12 — but require much more care and bear a far heftier price tag.

Cali is the first guide animal for Ramouni, 28, whose parents are Jordanian immigrants.

Ramouni says her parents aren’t fond of animals in general, although they did let her have a pet rabbit and are warming to the pony who lives in a small enclosure in the yard of their tidy brick home in Dearborn, Michigan.

And after some initial trepidation about how their daughter would fare with only a miniature horse to watch out for her, they have begun to trust that Ramouni will be okay on her own.

“My whole world and my whole outlook on stuff has changed, because I feel that there are a lot more possibilities,” Ramouni tells a visiting reporter.

“Before Cali, I didn’t feel like I could go places on my own, although theoretically I probably could have.”

Ramouni was taught as a child how to guide herself with a cane, but never really took to it. With six siblings, there was always someone around to take her by the arm.

She began looking into guide horses on a whim, becoming more determined to make it happen every time someone told her she couldn’t — or shouldn’t.

There was the neighbor who tried to get the city council to deny her a permit for Cali’s shed. The nasty e-mails from people attacking her family’s religious beliefs.

And then there was all the work it took to find a trainer, find a horse and learn how to trust and care for Cali.

Ramouni bought the three-year-old former show pony in October 2008 and sent her to professional trainer Dolores Artse, who spent seven months teaching Cali to tap her hoof to point out obstacles, get in and out of cars and buses, and even pick up misplaced objects.

It generally takes six months to a year for the relationship with a service animal to solidify and Ramouni’s first six weeks with Cali have been intense.

“I’m working with Cali. She’s working with me. We’re sort of figuring each other out,” Ramouni says.

“She is the most awesome little horse. If she can do it, if she thinks she can do it, she will. If she feels that there is a possibility for her to do it, she will try with all her heart.”

Cali is also a show-stopper: they can’t go anywhere without people stopping to ask about her.

And Ramouni, whose sisters used to call her antisocial because she would spend hours alone in her room, has found that she has become “more involved with the world… and more visible to the world” because of Cali.

That is the intention of the Americans with Disability Act, which protects against discrimination and requires that businesses, such as restaurants, hotels and stores allow entry to service animals.

But proposed changes to the act could narrow the definition of service animals to “a dog or other common domestic animal.”

Not only could Cali be turned away from businesses — like the McDonald’s down the street from Ramouni’s office — but the city of Dearborn could also decide to lift the zoning waiver that allows the horse to live in Ramouni’s yard.

If that happens, the city will have to send someone to pry Cali’s bridle from her hands, Ramouni says.

With Cali at her side, Ramouni can do simple things most people take for granted like go the store, sit in the park and listen to people going by, or take the bus to work. She also hopes to get a doctorate in child psychology and open her own practice.

“I just basically want to have a normal life,” she says, before laughing. “Yeah, after this you think I’m going to have an ordinary life? But that’s really what I want.”

Editor:

Concerning the Star-Tribune Editorial Board’s comments titled “Emotion shouldn’t rule debate on wild horses” (July 19), I contend that a healthy dose of passion may be priceless, when combined with improved federal law (Restore Our American Mustangs Act, or H.R. 1018), and data-run scientific management.

Please click on photo to comment on letter

Please click on photo to comment on letter

Politics and zeal walk hand in hand, while hard science endeavors to raise blurred biases closer to reality. The Bureau of Land Management’s Wild Horse and Burro Program has failed, due to perennial underfunding, conservative politics, disdain for activists, and lack of rock-solid science.

Rep. Cynthia Lummis, R-Wyo., has consistently allowed political motives to rule her decision-making, without reading the rich history of the wild horse protective movement or examining legal issues with an oil-immersion microscope. Factual errors in her statements are clearly reflected in this editorial piece, as though she had written it herself.

How easy to pronounce wild horses “feral” intruders on the American landscape, when not a shred of evidence is presented. Published mitochondrial-DNA and paleontological data substantiate not only 57 million years of evolutionary history for the Family Equidae in North America, but the presence of the caballoid horse prior to late-Pleistocene extinction. The American Museum of Natural History and The Science and Conservation Center at ZooMontana concur. Wild horses are a reintroduced native wildlife species in North America. Period.

This editorial fails to mention that censusing to create legal herd areas, after the 1971 Wild Free-Roaming Horses and Burros Act passed, began in 1974, during just one season of the year, disregarding herd migration. The ROAM Act endeavors to re-establish millions of legal acreages gone astray. It also disregards immunocontraceptive (fertility) control, available to the BLM for more than 20 years but not implemented scientifically.

Lastly, Appropriate Management Levels, set by range monitoring and horse counts, are questionable on many Herd Management Areas. Gov. Dave Freudenthal and the BLM may thump their Microsoft Excel sheets as though the Almighty had created them, but this program is dysfunctional, and only the ROAM Act will begin the healing process. Let emotion, improved law, and good science triumph.

PATRICIA M. FAZIO, Ph.D., Cody

Statewide coordinator, Wyoming Wild Horse Coalition

The U.S. House recently passed the “Restore Our American Mustangs Act,” which would protect wild horses in 10 western states by providing additional land and protections. But Rep. Doc Hastings, (R-Wash.) isn’t a huge fan.

Barbi Twins and Amy Nelson speak out on the horse issue (cilck image to hear podcast)

Barbi Twins and Amy Nelson speak out on the horse issue (cilck image to hear podcast)

“With all of the issues that are facing our country,” Hastings told POLITICO, “here we are going to the floor in order to fill time to talk about welfare for wild horses… It just doesn’t seem to make any sense to me.”

But Hastings and others with reservations about the bill have three passionate opponents: former Playboy playmates Shane and Sia Barbi (aka “The Barbi Twins”) and Amy Nelson, daughter of country superstar Willie Nelson. (Willie sits on the Board of Directors of Habitat for Horses)

“I gotta be honest: I’m very pro-snake. I’m an animal activist,” said Shane Barbi. “But these people are snakes in the way that they’re trying to disguise themselves as someone that cares about” animals

. “Sometimes they blurt out, ‘How can you do this in a time of a recession. Well, bottom line: The voters want to help animals no matter how bad times are.”

Nelson thinks Obama will support their issue. “He’s a compassionate and intelligent person,” said Nelson.

Washington Activist Blasts Political Opportunists Using Issue

By R.T. Fitch

HOUSTON (SFHH) – On July 18th, 2009 an Associated Press story hit the internet quoting sources saying  the Confederated Tribes of Warm Springs, Oregon would attempt to reintroduce horse slaughter into the United States.
The headline, “Groups Push to Slaughter Horses for Meat Possibly in Oregon” swept across the internet like wild fire.

Author R.T. Fitch

Author R.T. Fitch

“Native Americans and others are pushing for the renewed slaughter of horses in the U.S..and processing them into meat,” The AP story said.  “..The Confederated Tribes of Warm Springs are considering building a slaughter and
processing facility on their reservation north of Madras, as recommended last spring by a coalition of Northwest tribes.”

The story by Dick Cockle is inaccurate.  Several days of data mining and calls to the Confederated Tribes of Warm Springs has brought forth information that refutes virtually everything Cockle reported.  “No, we are not making any plans to build a horse slaughter plant on any reservation”, stated Tim Outman, field representative for the Warm Springs Tribe’s Department of Natural Resources.  Putting all cultural and moral conflicts aside, Outman said, “Who would invest 8-10 million dollars into building a facility where there is absolutely no market?  Shipping horse meat is against Federal Law.  We have no idea what, where or who, is perpetuating this misinformation.”

“This sort of journalism does nothing to further the cause and public relations of the Confederated Tribes of Warm Springs”, stated Outman

The AP also misquoted Chris Hyde of Washington’s Animal Welfare Institute (AWI) to such a point that Mr. Hyde responded, in disgust saying, “Richard Cockle has again written another poorly researched and unsupported article
on horses. I spent a great deal of time on the phone with him providing facts and evidence dismissing the misleading claims put forward by individuals more interested in abusing horses than advancing the truth.  However, what does he do? Prints rhetoric. It is a shame that Mr. Cockle, Sue Wallis and others continue to exploit the truth and suffering of horses just to make a name for themselves nationally”

“It is amazing how sloppy reporters have been on this issue.  The tribes are smart enough to see a scam and this is one of the worst.  The misinformation on this issue seems to be radiating from a very pro-horse slaughter vet from the region who just happens to be a leader of the so called “Unwanted” Horse Coalition.  As we all know this is a front group for the horse slaughter industry.”

Wallis is a Wyoming politician attempting to bring horse slaughter back to the United States.

R.T. Fitch is the author of the much acclaimed book, “Straight from the Horse’s Heart

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Bookmark and Share

Alright, it has finally happened, I have reached the tipping point.  Day after day the American public is bombarded with main stream media stories about all of the “unwanted” horses that are set free and running all over the US.  To take the stories for their word there should be a horse on every street corner in America begging for a bale of hay or a cup of grain but have you seen one?  I know that I haven’t.

Equine author R.T. Fitch speaks out against "pro" slaughter fabrications

Equine author R.T. Fitch speaks out against "pro" slaughter fabrications


As a voting citizen, of this great land, I am shocked and appalled by the volume of mistruths and simple bald faced lies that are fed to the general public…I feel like an idiot as I thought that such a practice was both illegal and unethical and could never, ever happen here, but it does.

The tale of the unwanted and abandoned horse is a lie, in fact, a documented falsehood in the great state of Texas.  Every other day a green or inexperienced reporter is pressured by the pro-slaughter machine to print, or report, on a trumped up story about how several horses “were just let loose” because there are no bloody slaughter plants open to kill them.  What a crock.  Abandoning an animal in the state of Texas is a crime, where is/was law enforcement?  Was the Sheriff called?  Was an investigation conducted?  Are there criminal charges pending?  Answer: No!!  No, because there were never any abandoned horses to begin with and what the “pro” people don’t want the public to know is that even without slaughter plants operating in the U.S., more healthy, young American horses were butchered for human consumption last year than when the plants were open in the U.S…they are now sent to Mexico and Canada to be brutalized.

When is this trail of lies, deceit and blood money going to end?  Why are so many people interested in whipping out all of our wild horses and killing our gentle companions for pennies on the dollar?  When are we going to stand up and say “Enough is enough”?

I have reached that precipice, that edge where I sincerely can not stand it any longer.  I don’t know about you, but I am raising my hand and screaming “Enough is enough, I can’t take it anymore!”   From now on the perpetrators of the lies will be publicly dogged for the truth, required to supply proof, nothing will be taken as fact until proper documentation has been rendered.  It’s time to hold the media accountable and by doing so we may be able to drive the liars and the deceivers back under the slimy rocks that they have crawled out from under.  I am putting the enemy on notice and warning them that they have no idea of what or whom they are dealing with.

Let the battle begin…it’s to the death and the bright light of the truth will always make the vermin scurry for cover.

The Force of the Horse will not be denied.

R.T. Fitch
Author – “Straight from the Horse’s Heart
The Force of the Horse®, LLC
1-800-974-FOTH
www.rtfitch.com
www.habitatforhorses.org

Bookmark and Share