By Kristen Moulton | The Salt Lake Tribune
First Published May 06 2014 01:18 pm • Last Updated May 06 2014 10:10 pm
Cattlemen continue war on Wild Horses
The BLM wanted to set up four more such “traps,” Miller said, and he wasn’t sure Tuesday whether the eight were captured in the original trap or a new one.The Bureau of Land Management on Monday removed eight wild horses from private land northwest of Cedar City, an Iron County commissioner said Tuesday.
“We’re pleased with anything, but it’s a drop in the bucket,” said Commission Chairman David Miller.
Iron and Beaver counties have been pressing the BLM to round up horses because there are far more than the agency’s own prescribed limits. According to May 1 numbers, the BLM estimates it has nearly 1,700 wild horses in western Iron and Beaver counties, an area where there are supposed to be just more than 600.
Ranchers say the horses are competing with cattle for feed and water, and the counties are threatening roundups this summer if the BLM doesn’t act.
To provide emergency relief in early April, the BLM set up corrals around a water trough on private land, but as of a week ago, not a single horse had been captured…(READ MORE)
Categories: Horse News, Horse Slaughter, Wild Horses/Mustangs
The hell with the ranchers!!!!! The horses have more of a right to this land than they do!!!!!
LikeLike
yes this s so right.
LikeLike
I feel the same way you do , we have to follow the law and they don’t who are they?
LikeLike
They are criminal law breakers who belong behind bars !!!!!!!!!!
LikeLike
We pay for those horses to graze and Roam , darn it … They have all the Rights to the Land !!!!!
LikeLike
It is their land they won it in court years a go…and the water rights.
LikeLike
What is the Law,it should be upheld !!!!!! what the hell is the problem, the law states it is and belongs to the Mustangs………………..It is the Job of the Government to up hold the Law !!!! Now remove those darn cattle pronto !!!!!
LikeLike
Please go ahead and discuss your opinion with BLM head of WHB program in Utah. jpalma@blm.gov. I suggested he get the cattle and sheep reduced on the horse herd areas so they are not forced to migrate onto private lands for forage. Seems kind of wierd to me that they don’t see that overgrazing public lands to save their own causes the conflict they complain of. If it is really the problem they say it is. So I brought that up to Mr Palma’s attention. Maybe he didn’t thoink of that yet.
LikeLike
I suggest they randomly PZP dart the cattle and sheep while they are out there, it’s only fair. I might even volunteer to help out since I know they are cash strapped and have bills to pay for the Bundy Botch.
LikeLike
There will come a time when everything will compete with humans for feed and water if we don’t rein our own activities in. Every creature has a right to feed and water that was put here for all creatures on this planet. We’re taking waaaaaayyyy more than our rightful share.
LikeLike
This is their land and their water rights, that the cattle are on, it belongs to the horses and the cattle are on the horses land, and yet hey fence out the horses from drinking their water, now using traps of water to catch them. Can’ t others see the wrong in this and theses acts?
LikeLike
Just looking at this picture takes my breath away …
LikeLike
Dear kaitlin , the pure innocent beauty presented by a horse, can take your breath away in a most beautiful way………………..
LikeLike
Beauty in motion.
LikeLike
PUBLIC LAND LAW REVIEW
http://scholarship.law.umt.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1074&context=plrlr
An analysis of the Wild Horses Act and the relevant case law will demonstrate that the prevailing method used to eliminate the “straying problem”-extensive governmental removal of horses from public and private lands-COUNTERMANDS the protective purposes of the Act and of related public lands statutes.
LikeLike
PUBLIC LAND LAW REVIEW
http://scholarship.law.umt.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1074&context=plrlr
While the constitutional basis for § 1334’s regulation of conduct on private lands remains an open issue, several persuasive theories suggest that Congress was EMPOWERED TO EXTEND FEDERAL CONTROL BEYOND PUBLIC BOUNDRIES.
LikeLike
PUBLIC LAND LAW REVIEW
http://scholarship.law.umt.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1074&context=plrlr
Section 1334 of the Wild Horses Act provides landowners an
inexpensive and convenient method of removing straying horses from their
private property.
The BLM is under a “MINISTERAL DUTY” TO RETURN THE HORSES TO THE PUBLIC RANGE.
LikeLike
Fordham Environmental Law Review
http://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1394&context=elr
In its natural state, wildlife has always been regarded as ferae
naturae, a part of the commons rather than private property.92 Since
Roman law, government has been recognized as the trustee of wildlife
for the benefit of the public.
Modern doctrines imply that the states and the federal government share a strong parens patriae interest in
wildlife conservation.
For instance, in Kleppe v. New Mexico,’°4 the Court upheld
the right of the government to protect wild horses and burros
despite claims of damage to private grazing-rights holders.
LikeLike
How do we know that the Cattle Ranchers who are publicly Angry ( the BLM is not rounding up the Wild Mustang Horses in a mass roundup on public lands at their demand ) are not running Wild Horses onto their properties and into the BLM Traps?? Who’s Watching??? The BLM says was it an older trap or was it one of the new traps the BLM set ???? Really?? How many traps are set on private lands??? If the BLM places 4 more traps on ranchers private lands and they run 6-8 Wild Horses in per Trap x 5….( and place that many more on private lands without public knowledge )… It takes approx. 30 horses to fill a slaughter truck…The ranchers know the BLM will go on private land and take Wild Mustang Horses… Quickly and Sell them Quickly, Quietly … Only because of “National Publicity” does the country know these 8 Wild Mustang Horses are captured. The BLM does not allow the public to observe any Wild Horse captures. The BLM has “No Records” to account for the “Exact Number” of Wild Mustang Horses captured….NONE…The BLM is not required to “Computer Chip” a captured Wild Mustang Horse …..”National Publicity” of Wild Horse captures… alert the public…I don’t think the BLM want’s any National publicity…..They are zeroing out Wild Horses on 1,000’s of Public Land areas designated for Wild Mustang Horses to Live….The BLM hold’s public inquires for public opinion while quietly continuing to “remove” the last of Our Historic American Wild Mustang Horses
…. Americans Are Not This Naive!!!
LikeLike