Horse News

Born to Be Wild

by as published on Eugene Weekly

“Though revered by much of the public, wild horses across the West are also the subject of a 70-year controversy involving locals, the Bureau of Land Management (BLM), activists and ranchers…”

Steens HMA wild horse family ~ photo by R.T. Fitch of Wild Horse Freedom Federation

Their stillness makes them almost imperceptible. But I know they are out there, so I cup my hands around my eyes and squint into the late afternoon sunlight, scanning the high desert for any sign of movement.

Suddenly, they appear: Nearly a dozen wild mustangs grazing in scattered groups on the hillside. Lingering beneath a partly cloudy sky, they look painted onto the landscape.

The air smells of dirt and sagebrush as I stand by my car parked on the side of Steens Mountain Loop Road, on the western flank of the mountain in southeast Oregon. Around me, the wilderness is silent except for a bevy of Western meadowlarks, who, perching on desert plants, tip their heads back and serenade anything passing by.

These horses are the South Steens mustangs, one of more than 17 herds that traverse Oregon’s public lands. Oregon has more than 6,100 wild horses, according to estimates, just a small fraction of the nearly 95,000 that live throughout the Western states. Most live in Nevada.

Though revered by much of the public, wild horses across the West are also the subject of a 70-year controversy involving locals, the Bureau of Land Management (BLM), activists and ranchers. This complicated dispute, intertwining passion and harsh realities, debates what it means to be wild, what it means to have a home and what it means to protect a horse.

To learn more about Oregon’s wild horses, Eugene Weekly took a trip to the remote southeast corner of the state, trading Douglas-fir trees for the sparse high desert landscape some of these horses call home. The South Steens herd, like many other herds in Oregon, wandered through these lands ungoverned and unprotected for centuries until the BLM began managing them in 1971. The agency has been responsible for horses on BLM land ever since.

From plains to pens

“You occasionally see one, and it’s the thrill of a lifetime. But mostly all you ever see is a cloud of dust after they are gone. It’s their stubborn ability to survive that makes them so remarkable.” — Velma “Wild Horse Annie” Johnston

Before the BLM managed wild horses, the mustangs were fair game for any rancher or cowboy who wanted to round up mustangs and slaughter them for commercial purposes. In the 1950s, Velma Johnston, a secretary from Nevada known as “Wild Horse Annie,” became aware of how badly wild horses were treated and led a grassroots campaign against some of the worst abuses.

She recruited school students to help, and thousands of letters later, Congress responded by passing the 1959 Wild Horse Annie Act, which prohibited the use of motor vehicles to hunt wild horses on public lands, but did not further protect the horses.

“There was no protection for wild horses,” says Rob Sharp, program supervisor at the Oregon BLM wild horse corrals a few miles west of Burns. “People were rounding them up. A lot of it was for slaughter purposes.”

By 1971, the wild horse population on public lands declined because of the continued permitted gathering and slaughtering of horses. In response to public protest, Congress passed the Wild Free-Roaming Horses and Burros Act, which gives the management and protection of wild horses on most public land to the BLM. It was signed into law that year by President Richard Nixon. There are other herds that live on reservations and land managed by the forest service, for example the Big Summit Herd in the Ochoco National Forest.

Then the question came: How would the BLM manage the horses? One answer came from Harney County during an extreme drought in the 1970s, says Pauline Braymen, a third generation rancher near Burns and former editor of the Burns Times-Herald as well as a correspondent for The Oregonian.

“It was the worst drought of my life,” recalls Braymen, now in her 80s. “Malheur Lake was dry. You could just drive across it.”

Braymen says the drought led the BLM to conduct one of its first “gathers” of wild horses. A gather is when the agency removes wild horses and burros to, ideally, protect the health of the animals and range land. In 1977, they rounded up the Palomino Butte herd into trailers, taking the horses away from the BLM land they lived on, called herd management areas (HMA).

“Horses in Harney County, especially the Beatys Butte Herd, would have perished if they hadn’t been gathered,” Braymen says, who loves horses, but doesn’t ride them.

Equine Photographer, Carol Walker, gathering pictorial documentation of the Oregon Steens herd – by R.T. Fitch

For many years, horse gathers were selective. The BLM put back horses with certain markings that were representative of the herd. With the South Steens, it’s pinto, a horse with patches of white and another color.

“They selected the horses that they thought were the best horses, and the colors and the markings and all,” Braymen says. The famous Kiger mustangs — which are descended from Spanish horses — were rounded up at Beatys Butte, southwest of Steens Mountain, and were placed near the northern part of the mountain in and near Kiger Gorge. This geographic isolation keeps the Kiger DNA local.

Debate persists about whether horses are wild or feral. The BLM says the horses are feral, because they are non-native to North America, and the first horses introduced were domesticated animals brought by Spanish Conquistadors in the 1500s.

Horses evolved in North America before disappearing from the fossil record, and advocates point to research suggesting Indigenous peoples had horses before Spaniards arrived in America.

Joan Suther, a former BLM field manager and a biologist in Burns, says that over the centuries, ranchers left their horses on public lands when they couldn’t take care of them.

“If you do genetic testing, there is a whole lot of mixing going on,” Suther says, adding that the South Steens herd is not descended from Spanish mustangs.

Even if some horses were once feral, many people have their own idea of where to draw the line between feral and wild. Sonya Spaziani, known to many as “Mustang Meg,” documents Oregon herds, including the South Steens, and advocates for their protection with her organization, Mustang Wild.

“In my opinion, ‘feral’ is often misused in a derogatory context,” she says. “It should be directly applied to a horse in a feral situation that was domestic and then turned loose. Now, if that horse gives birth then the subsequent offspring is wild.”

Spaziani says she’s learned from geneticists that thousands of years of domestication have not changed the biology of the horse. A horse that is turned loose will quickly regain the natural instincts, she says.

“Once they are born wild, they are wild.”

Home off the range

BLM Hines Holding Facility outside of Burns, Oregon~ Photo by R.T. Fitch

The BLM corrals sprawl across 320 acres of land in low hills about a quarter mile off of Highway 20 west of Burns. About 600 wild horses, collected from all over the region, fill 41 pens, lined by tall fences so the horses can’t jump out. They are separated by age and gender. The horses stay here for the next few years until they are either adopted or moved onto another range.

A gravel road wraps around the corrals, an auto tour for both interested adopters and other tourists. Some pens hold several dozen mustangs. Their colorings are all unique — pinto, black, chestnut, bay and dun. When we arrive early in the morning, the horses munch on freshly delivered hay, on which the Oregon BLM spends $1 million — half its horse budget — each year.

The horses in the corrals still have thick winter coats in late April, a necessity in the freezing air that persists despite soft morning sunlight. As we drive around on the auto tour road, the horses don’t mind too much when we approach the fence with caution. Sometimes they scatter and other times they just go back to eating. The foals are the most unfazed by approaching humans.

“This is often where the journey starts for every animal coming into this facility,” Sharp says.

Every herd has a management population number range, Sharp says, which is the number of animals the BLM determines can sustainably occupy geographic areas.

One of the most efficient ways of gathering, Sharp says, is to round them up by helicopter, a method that is opposed by many advocates because it exhausts the horses and sometimes leads to death. BLM can also set up a bait trap, which lures the horses into one area or using a trained mustang called a “Judas horse” to lead others into a corral.

Another reason the BLM says it gathers horses is because of their rate of reproduction. But horses give birth to one offspring at a time, whereas sheep and sometimes cows can give birth to twins. In the wild, mustangs are resilient, and if they face a shortage of resources they will find other ways to survive.

8 month old fillies at BLM’s Hines, Oregon holding facility ~ photo by R.T. Fitch

Clare Staples, who runs a wild horse and burro rescue called Skydog Ranch and Sanctuary based in Prineville, argues that though the BLM used to gather for genetics, it now does it to keep numbers low. “The number of horses in holding pens gets larger and larger,” she says.

Many activists think the BLM prioritizes beef ranchers’ demands for space to graze cattle. Livestock don’t live on range year round — they graze from April to September in Oregon — but they still outnumber the horses on BLM land, where ranchers pay as little as $1.35 a month to graze one cow-calf pair. Advocates say it wastes taxpayer money to hold horses in pens, while other livestock have access to the land for cheap.

Sharp says that ranchers who want their livestock to graze on BLM land have to acquire a permit, which means the BLM can limit the number of grazing livestock if resources are scarce for mustangs.

Scott Beckstead is the manager of campaigns for the Animal Wellness Action and Center for a Humane Economy. He says the BLM has become increasingly resentful of its position.

“This is seen in their pro livestock duties,” Beckstead says. “They are weaving this false narrative and are taking cues from the beef industry.”

After an animal is taken off the range, the BLM will process it: giving the horse vaccines and a BLM freeze brand on the neck. Mares are given contraceptives that last about a year. Any horse that doesn’t end up back on the range is available for adoption at a price of around $125. Even so, adoption rates are low.

The BLM started an adoption incentive program in 2019, which pays qualifying individuals a total of $1,000 to adopt an ungentled horse. After one year the horse belongs to the adopter.

“Since the launch of the incentive program, we adopt out about 400 animals a year,” Sharp says, which is double from previous years. If a horse doesn’t get adopted within about two years, they are sent to live permanently on range in another state.

This morning at the BLM site, an adopter arrives to pick up a horse. When the mare is loaded in the trailer, she thunders back and forth, frantic and confused. The trailer shakes, and the adopter assures the horse she is on her way to a better life…(CONTINUED)

Born to Be Wild

4 replies »

  1. Great article. The author was” breathless” after looking eye to eye with a mustang; most people would be. It’s a great privilege and seldom realized. While Scott Beckstead’s comment, “We want them protected and to live wild and free because we as a people value freedom,” is good, it’s important to remember that the horse arose, evolved on our tectonic plate and traveled to other continents. They survived the Ice Age leaving DNA in Alaska’s interior. There is more evidence and more could be unearth or found if there was will to do so. We should take care of them, because they truly are native and humans relied on them so much.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Dave Phillips on the corrupt “adoption” policies of the BLM:

    “In a lifetime of working with horses, Gary Kidd, 73, had never adopted an untrained wild mustang before. But when the federal government started paying people $1,000 a horse to adopt them, he signed up for as many as he could get. So did his wife, two grown daughters and a son-in-law.

    Mr. Kidd, who owns a small farm near Hope, Ark., said in a recent telephone interview that he was using the mustangs, which are protected under federal law, to breed colts and that they were happily eating green grass in his pasture.

    In fact, by the time he spoke on the phone, the animals were long gone. Records show that Mr. Kidd had sold them almost as soon as he legally could. He and his family received at least $20,000, and the mustangs ended up at a dusty Texas livestock auction frequented by slaughterhouse brokers known as kill buyers.

    When asked about the sale, Mr. Kidd abruptly hung up.”

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Dave Phillips is getting better but not there yet on his facts. Where he gets them is obviously from the BLM. A 20% yearly population growth rate could only happen if stallions had foals; 100k wild horses on the ranges – can’t be due to horses being taken off the range all the time and taken to holding where trucks never leave empty. Processing plant numbers are greater than what the BLM declares. “There are now more than 51,000 animals in holding, eating up so much of the program’s budget — about $60 million a year — that the bureau has little left to manage mustangs in the wild.” This $1000/horse give away to people whom BLM knows will only turn around and sell wild horses at auction is totally Machiavellian. BLM greatly undercharges the grifters’ grazing fees, so taxpayers have to subsidize livestock ripping up the range. Lastly the NYT should be a true editor on Phillips’ articles rather than accepting funny numbers complacently.


Care to make a comment?

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.