Horse News

BLM Ignores Calico Wild Horse Advocates’ Concerns

Story by Maureen HarmonayEquine Advocacy Examiner

Behind Locked Gates the BLM Acts with Total Secrecy and Zero Transparency

Wild Horse advocates R.T. Fitch, Elyse Gardener and Ginger Kathrens trying to get answers from BLM at Pryor Mt. Round-up

For the last 11 days, the BLM has been trying to make it seem that there is nothing we need to know about the captive wild horses form the Calico Mountains who are currently being held in a closed door feedlot in Fallon, Nevada.  Day after day, since April 10th, the agency’s Gather Daily Updates have contained essentially the same message:

“Most stallions and weaned colts are doing well and gaining weight.  Mares from Black Rock East, Black Rock West and most Granite horses continue to do well.  Mares from Warm Springs and Calico are improving.  Mares that have been isolated for poor condition are gaining weight.  No miscarriages occurred.  Mares are actively foaling and new foals are born daily.”

In the absence of relevant details, observers have no choice but to read between the lines.  On Friday, April 16th, we learned that the BLM had started to castrate all male horses aged four and under.  It’s hard to believe that the gelding has progressed without incident, but the BLM has been mum.  What little we know about how the colts and young stallions are being castrated comes from the report of Dr. Eric Davis, who has inspected the Fallon facility on two different occasions, on behalf of the Humane Society of the U.S.

In his February 13th report, Dr. Davis said that BLM veterinarian Dr. Richard Sanford uses “an ultra short acting paralytic agent,” succinylcholine, to immobilize the horses “prior to the administration of a xylazine and ketamine combination, which causes unconsciousness and analgesia.”

According to Restraint and Handling of Wild and Domestic Animals, by noted veterinarian Dr. Murray E. Fowler:

“Succinylcholine is the most rapidly acting immobilizing agent available.  Succinylcholine and other similar agents have been used extensively in wild animal immobilization in the past, but newer, non-paralyzing agents have supplanted them. . .

Animals appear to be bewildered by the whole experience.  Psychological stress is associated with being unable to fight or flee–the normal alarm response.”

So in addition to the residual physical pain of the castration procedure, the young Calico mustang males are experiencing profound emotional stress from their inability to control what is happening to them.

Have the gelding operations resulted in any complications?  We don’t know.  Have any horses had to be resuscitated because they stopped breathing?  Dr. Fowler warns that “cessation of respiration is a natural result of succinylcholine immobilization.  Procedures should not be attempted without resuscitation equipment available.”  And indeed, Dr. Davis’s report confirms that such equipment is on standby for “horses that became apneic (stopped breathing).  Apparently, this does happen occasionally using the described anesthesia protocol, and there have been a very small number of deaths occur.”

If any of the castrations have been anything but routine, the BLM isn’t admitting it.  All it will say, as it did today, is that “the gelding of four years and younger horses is underway and will continue until completed.”

Bookmark and Share

Equine Advocacy Examiner, Maureen Harmonay

Maureen Harmonay has been a passionate equine advocate since the 1970s, when she bred and raced thoroughbreds and worked as a thoroughbred bloodstock agent. More recently, she has spoken out on behalf of horses in her blog, and in her Boston Animal Advocacy column. Maureen is an avid supporter of the efforts of Americans Against Horse Slaughter, and she is the proud “mom” of a retired Premarin mare, Hayley, whom she adopted from Bay State Equine Rescue in Oakham, MA.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

2 replies »

  1. Thank you for this informative info. I feel so storngly for thses horses and the terror they must be still, STILL enduring. After watching the recent video of the Calico horses being processed I was agast at the total absense of any concern by those doing the processing. They were so disengaged as to actually look bored. They truly do not care, and I don’t care what anyone else says about how great these people are – I just do not see it.

    I was wondering though if there were not some way to make those horses “waiting” more comfortable. I know dog groomers have aerosols that they use to calm dogs. I have some powder that I give one of my dogs before grooming, as he is otherwise terrified. Isn’t there something they could be doing differently (other than not rounding up and not processing in the first place of course)?


  2. More horses are entering the dead end future of BLM ‘management.’ No thought for selective management has emerged from these people. If they capture highly prized “Curleys” and other desired combinations will these horses be spared?? Would we ever know if they have been?? How much influence do the silent wild horse “Mustang Breeders?” have with BLM? Where are they while all these bloodlines and fine individuals we see are being stolen from their rightful range? The silence of many is very loud. Does that make them complicit?Are their back room deals for horses with highly desired traits? Will such horses just be placed into sales if they are over adoption age?
    Our horses need a kingdom. mar


Care to make a comment?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.