Horse News

What Do We Owe the Horse? Government Considering Slaughterhouse Proposal

Source: Michael D'Antonio
Author, Mortal Sins, Sex, Crime, and the Era of Catholic Scandal ~published in the Huffington Post

“The human response to the horse suggests that as he was evolving in relationship to us, we were adapting to him…”

Last week a video appeared on YouTube showing a man cursing animal rights activists, then leading a friendly, fit-looking horse out of a pen, and shooting it dead with a single pistol shot between its eyes. (The horse was so tame it quietly stepped toward the pistol, and dipped its head to receive a scratch, in the moment before the shot

Tim Sappington is employed by a meatpacking company that has proposed to start slaughtering horses in New Mexico, bringing the practice back to American soil. The video inflamed opponents to the slaughterhouse. Rick De Los Santos, owner of Valley Meat Company, said he received so many threatening phone calls that he hired a security company to protect himself and his business.

In New Mexico, no law prevents a man from killing his own horse if the act is carried out humanely. Local officials declared that Sappington did kill humanely. However it’s hard to imagine that anyone who saw the video, felt anything but anger at the man and sorrow for the horse. In 21st-century America, at least, killing a horse for meat, or to prove it can be done “humanely,” breaks a compact that has grown stronger even as the horse has disappeared from most of our lives.

Check the news on any given day there’s a good chance you’ll see something about a horse. Last summer it was Ann Romney’s dressage champion Rafalca, which Steven Colbert playfully mocked for its performance in Olympic “horse prancing.” After Rafalca came a runaway carriage horse in Manhattan. More recently a horsemeat scandal swallowed-up the Swedish meatball business at all the in-store eateries operated by IKEA.

Beyond the news, horses show up regularly in our art. After a solid Broadway run and a Tony award for best play, War Horse is selling-out a national tour. The portrait show dubbed “most beautiful” of the season by The New York Times is Charlotte Dumas’s exhibit of photos Army horses at Arlington National Cemetery. In March artist Nick Cave thrilled commuters with performances of dancers on horse costumes at Grand Central Station.

Cave and Dumas are direct descendants of Paleolithic artists who painted images of dashing horses inside caves in France and scraped the image of one out of topsoil in Oxfordshire. Ancients considered the horse an important subject because it was so much a part of daily life. No animal has served us more thoroughly — as athlete, transport, tool, and warrior – or more reliably. All this service was rendered thanks to human intervention. We made the horse a partner above all others in the animal world. We also made it dependent on us for its well-being.

The industrial revolution began, for most of us, the end of contact with horses. But distant as we may be from everyday interaction with them, the horse still evokes deep emotions that are more wide-ranging and visceral than what we feel in response to any other animal. Dogs may move us to fear, affection, or admiration. In rare moments certain breeds will even act heroically on our behalf. But we do not need a special moment to be moved by the horse. Even people who fear them marvel at the sight of such a large and powerful creature acting in such close relationship with relatively puny human beings.

For millennia, people have anthropomorphized the horse and it’s now almost impossible for us to avoid reading some feeling into a snort, a twitch, or the blink of an eye. Current research supports at least some of our interpretations. From Iain Douglas-Hamilton’s study of grieving elephants to The Emotional Lives of Animals by Marc Bekoff, the argument for the idea that other species experience deep feelings gets stronger every day. Those of us who have experienced the varied “personalities” of animals know this research will eventually lead to a general agreement that many species have feelings similar to ours. From this realization it is a short step to profound questions about our duty to the animals we have domesticated.

The human response to the horse suggests that as he was evolving in relationship to us, we were adapting to him. Survival of the fittest might well have included survival of those humans who could work with the horse. Human beings who excelled at the care and training of horses enjoyed obvious advantages and were more likely to thrive and, consequently, love the horse.

If we have evolved to bond with the horse on an emotional level, then our feelings explain this animal’s continuing presence on our streets, in the pages of the newspapers, and in our art. This relationship also explains why one of the few recent bipartisan initiatives in Congress is a proposed ban on both horse slaughter and the export of American horses to countries where they may be killed for meat. In the House, the bill was sponsored by Republican Patrick Meehan of Pennsylvania and Democrat Jan Schakowsky. In the Senate it was proposed by Republican Lindsey Graham and Democrat Mary Landrieu, who noted “there’s no humane way to slaughter a horse.”

Considering their innate wariness and sharp senses, there may not be a humane way to slaughter horses, which is why the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, The Animal Welfare Institute and the American Humane Society support the proposed bans. Polls show a consistent majority of Americans also oppose horse slaughter. Local community opposition led to the closing of the last three horse slaughterhouses in the country in 2007. However in recent months Valley Meat’s effort to resume the practice in the United States has brought the prospect of horse slaughter into the public area…(CONTINUED)

Click (HERE) to read the story in it’s entirety and to Comment

10 replies »

  1. there can be no more killing of our horses the government has no say as to there murdering and American horse people will not stand for a president and his goons that want to murder our horses on our land not the dam governments lands war is comeing to American soil and sooner then you think


  2. Horse slaughter needs to be banned and President Obama needs to keep his promise and do just that.. No to opening horse slaughter plants in the USA they were closed in 2007 for many reasons and should not be able to come back again. 80% of the public does not want that predatory inhumane enterprise to show its ugly head again. We need to pass The Safeguard American Food Export Act of 2013 NOW it will ensure that these majestic animals are treated with the respect they deserve:) Our wild horses have to be free on our public land where they belong free from horse slaughter.


  3. Dave Tate you are right on— you know that old Tombstone saying Justice is coming and hell’s coming with it!!!!


  4. The real tragedy is that it is obvious that someone took the time to breed a healthy little colt. He wasn’t a bad guy by any means. Someone out there knew that little ctteetolt and it was out of someone’s mare. God help him if was a baby that I had breed. There are alot of things that are so called legal, but when it is exposed to the whole World to see the scenario changes. You are violating what I consider to be humane rights. One can only hope that this mean spirited man, I hope will burn in hell!! There are so many truths here about our wonderful and magnificient horses. What is wrong with them? I received a letter from my senator indicating the SAFE bill is not yet out of committee. The only I can say is, why not? I guess the next step is to contact everyone on the committee to show suppor for the bill.


  5. Gail, the committee members when the last bill was trapped in limbo are the ones I sent copies of the video filmed at Bouvry slaughter plant in Canada. Only one that bothered to answer it was senator John Cornyn of TX. He just told me up front that he was not going to vote to pass the bill. He said that it would take away the right of horse owners to do what ever they wanted to about their livestock and their property. Cornyn is one of the crooks that is given thousands of dollars by lobbyists from the racing industry, and all the numerous special interests that has kept any bill from passing. Its the US Senate that has blocked every bill that has been introduced for the past several years. This is why I have very little hope about S. 541 passing. You have to have both the House and the Senate to pass a bill like this. The last bill that died in committee had 160 cosponsors in the House and only 24 in the Senate. The only hope of stopping the slaughter is if the EU bans horse meat from Canada and Mexico as well as the US. Since we heard that they have banned horse meat from the US, w have to wait and see what happens about Canada.


  6. The horse, because it is a higher animal and well known for its many inherent qualities which man has lost, forgotten, or devalued in himself, has been a favorite scapegoat for what can only be called ritual abuse and sacrifice of the horse by man, for ages.

    Man especially envies the horse’s natural freedom and independence when unmolested, so he traps horses, breaks up their families, turns them into slaves who will submit to his whims and often sadistic perversions which humiliate them, cripple them and break their spirits, buys and sells them like used cars, and in the final act of man’s own self-betrayal which he has projected onto the horse all along, and is ashamed to face, he sends both himself and the horse to a violent and bloody death.

    Horse: the sacrificial scapegoat.

    I believe when man sees this truth he will stop shooting and slaughtering the messenger. How he perceives and treats the horse from birth to death is a mirror reflecting back to him his own self-betrayal. He has only to see through the horse’s eyes, which takes true courage.


Care to make a comment?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.