Horse News

Silence on Trump-Zinke Budget Plan Could Doom Wild Horses & Burros

Message from Return to Freedom Wild Horse Conservation

“Supporters of wild horses ought to contact their representatives right now…”

photo by Terry Fitch of Wild Horse Freedom Federation

Return to Freedom Wild Horse Conservation on Wednesday urged supporters of America’s iconic wild horses and burros to speak out on their behalf, and for Congress to stand against a presidential budget proposal that threatens the lives of tens of thousands of horses.

“Now is the time for our representatives to ask tough questions and demand a humane, sustainable on-the-range management plan for wild horses — rather than be left to explain their votes later, after healthy horses are shipped to slaughter or shot at taxpayer expense,” said Neda DeMayo, president of Return to Freedom.

“Likewise, supporters of wild horses ought to contact their representatives right now – not after such deadly provisions become law. Pick up a pen or the phone and make sure that Washington hears you, loud and clear, over the whispers of industry lobbyists.”

Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke took questions from the Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources on Tuesday and Senate Appropriations Subcommittee on the Interior on Wednesday. In nearly five hours of testimony, wild horse management received only fleeting mentions and Zinke’s prepared statement shed no new light on the administration’s plans.

The president’s budget would slash the Bureau of Land Management’s Wild Horse and Burro Program budget by 12%, about $9.7 million. The majority of the program’s budget goes to warehouse some 47,000 captured wild horses and burros living in short- and long-term government holding facilities.

The budget would cut those costs by allowing the BLM “to conduct sales without limitation,” eliminating the current policy of captured wild horses and burros being offered for sale without limitation when they reach 10 years of age or fail to be adopted three times. Many sold would likely fall into the hands of kill buyers.

The budget would also remove “language restricting BLM’s ability to use all of the management tools authorized in the 1971 [Wild Free-Roaming Horses and Burros] Act,” scrapping Congress’s prohibitions in previous appropriations bills that barred BLM from shooting healthy animals.

As part of the president’s focus on “all-of-the-above” energy production, Zinke repeatedly returned to the subject of a $15.5 billion drop in his department’s revenues and said that some of the $1.6 billion in proposed cuts could be lessened if revenues increase.

Zinke took a variety of questions about specific areas of concerns in the senators’ states, an ongoing review of national monuments, a large-scale reassignment of department employees, tribal issues and climate change. He defended an 84 percent cut of Interior’s Land and Water Conservation program by saying the country ought not buy more land but instead take better care of what it had.

So far, Zinke has shown little interest in humane management alternatives for wild horses.

Testifying about the budget before the Speaking House Appropriations Subcommittee on the Interior earlier this month, Zinke said that “the birth control part of the (Wild Horse) Program has been, by and large, a failure” – this despite BLM spending just $340,000 on fertility control in 2016 compared to $52.49 million on capturing and warehousing horses off the range, for example.

A 2013 National Academy of Sciences report identified fertility control as an effective tool for managing the wild horse population while blaming BLM’s system of capture and removal for promoting population growth. An economic model published that same year in the peer-reviewed Journal of Zoo and Wildlife Medicine found that the BLM could attain its management goals within 12 years by using fertility control.

In 2008, BLM was very close to achieving their desired population target and still they did not implement an effective fertility control program that has proven 91-98% successful in various programs.

Return to Freedom and other advocates have long called for redirecting money spent on capturing and holding wild horses toward available solutions that do not include the needless slaughter of healthy equines promised our protection.

These include not only using safe, proven fertility control but revisiting population targets, based on a fair interpretation of multiple-use land management; providing incentives for ranchers who reduce livestock grazing in wild horse Herd Management Areas; increasing range stewardship, including much-needed water source restoration; and relocating horses, but only if truly necessary.

Shooting healthy wild horses at taxpayer expense or selling them out the back door, where they wind up slaughtered in Canada or Mexico, would contradict the will of Congress and the American people.

The recently passed bipartisan omnibus bill defunded horse slaughter plant inspections and explicitly prohibits BLM from euthanizing healthy wild horses or selling horses in a way that results in their destruction. Since January 139 House members have also signed on as co-sponsors of the bipartisan HR 113 (Buchanan), dubbed the SAFE Act, which would permanently ban commercial horse slaughter or the transport of horses to slaughter.

The American people have repeatedly supported protections for wild horses and burros, dating to the public outcry that led the unanimous passage of the Wild Horse and Burro Act in 1971. Since then, taxpayers have invested tens of millions of dollars in the protection of wild horses on the range and after capture. A 2012 ASPCA poll found 80% of Americans opposed horse slaughter.

Take action: Send a letter to Congress!

8 replies »

  1. For whatever it’s worth, I called Murkowski and Udall’s offices and e-mailed Zinke at DOI, along with my senators and representative. Still wouldn’t congress have to repeal the Free Roam Act before defunding BLM’s programs for wild horses which congress entrusted BLM? Certainly, the House is very adept at defunding whatever program prescribed by law they chose to ignore, but this has been a long-standing law since 1971.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. As stated in this article,
    “… Zinke repeatedly returned to the subject of a $15.5 billion drop in his department’s revenues and said that some of the $1.6 billion in proposed cuts could be lessened if revenues increase.”

    Since Congress is concerned with the cost of long-term holding of wild horses and burros, and our public lands, please allow me to remind us all that these wild horses and burros already have legal lands in the wild for them to live on which cost the tax-payer nothing. In contrast, private/corporate livestock grazing on public lands has cost the taxpayers $1 Billion over past decade. The Government Accountability Office (GAO) has reported the federal government spends at least $144 million each year managing private livestock grazing on federal public lands, but collects only $21 million in grazing fees—for a net LOSS of at least $123 million per year.

    Click to access factsheet_Grazing_Fiscal_Costs(3).pdf

    Liked by 2 people

  3. From Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility (PEER)

    Buyouts to “Accelerate Attrition” While Meeting New Trump Agenda
    Posted on Jun 21, 2017

    After last November’s election, PEER sent surveys concerning resources, performance and direction to BLM managers, range, fire and scientific staff in nine Western states. Pertinent responses include:

    More than two-thirds of respondents do not think BLM has enough resources to accomplish its mission, with only a quarter saying it does;

    Less than a third “have confidence” in BLM Headquarters leadership or believe that the agency is “more capable” than it was five years ago; and

    Half of respondents agree with the statement “In my experience, energy development has come to dominate BLM priorities”–nearly double those who disagree.

    “Compared to staffing of other agencies, such as the Park Service, BLM is a bureaucratic Bangladesh,” added Ruch. “Its employees are saying that there is no blood left to be squeezed from the BLM turnip.”


  4. Please protect those horses. PLEASE they ard our heritage and have every right to live their lives free..


  5. These wild ponies have been occuping this land far longer than our country has been in existence. This is their land and you money hungry thrives are trying to evict them? How do you get away with paying off these jerks in Washington in order to have the right to do this? The law of nature is the law of the land and if your cattle can’t share their home with these ponies, then you need to find them another home! Curses to you for your evil plans


  6. Wow, I can’t believe this may happen , What in the world are you People thinking ? I know Money in your pocket ! These Wild Mustangs and Burros Generations have been on the lands out west for over Hundreds of years , And you plan to go in and take there home and land away from them too , and try and kill them off, Like the so called government did to the Indian Nation . I can’t believe your plains are to take so many Innocent Lives . What the hell is this country coming too ! You are making People pay taxes on feed for these horse in holding pins , and paying for the round up , When they are Perfectly fine on the open range . You say there starving I say you are lying ! I say you are making way for the Welfare Cattle Ranchers and sheep, we pay there taxes too., For the cattle can feed on the open range . Most of the beef in the U.S. is raised for shipment to China . Everyone knows the cow and sheep when they eat grass they put the whole thing out of the ground , where when the horses eat and burros they bite the top off and the grass grows again . It doesn’t Die ! Where is the Common Sense in that ?.The Cattle should be Regulated not the wild Mustangs And Burros .And the Cattle Ranchers should have the cattle on their land Not Public Lands . So you people in office want to be the Sorry Ass that take a Beautiful Animal such as the Mustangs and make them be 12th on the Extinction List .Leave it to Mankind to KILL MOTHER EARTH !!! Don’t you know Every Animal on this planet work together . Not Man He wants ! His greed Will Kill Us All.
    Wild Freedom Federation , founder Nancy Woodall


Care to make a comment?

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.