Ex-BLM head stood to benefit from sale of Henderson land, watchdog reports

SOURCE:  Lasvegassun.com

The inspector general’s report said Abbey’s “involvement in the land sale began early in the process,” as he “conversed or met with Ford on several occasions” before and during the initial sales efforts. According to the report:

• On March 4, 2011, Ford emailed Abbey, saying, “Glad we had time to catch up yesterday in Reno and happy we were able to visit candidly about issues of mutual interest (sic).”

abbey_t198 Bob Abbey

By

Bob Abbey, former head of the federal Bureau of Land Management, was “personally and substantially involved” in selling Henderson land for a multi-venue sports complex to developer Chris Milam and “stood to benefit personally” from the sale, says a new report from an internal government watchdog.

The Department of the Interior’s Office of Inspector General said in a report published Tuesday that it found “no evidence” that Milam bought the 480-acre project site from the BLM “with the intent to flip it,” as Henderson city officials alleged in a civil fraud case against the developer in 2013.

But, investigators said, Abbey had much to gain from Milam’s purchase, thanks to Abbey’s “business connection” to real estate consultant and former longtime BLM official Mike Ford.

Abbey and Ford are partners at Las Vegas-based consulting firm Abbey, Stubbs & Ford LLC. Abbey joined the firm in 2005 but resigned in 2009, when President Barack Obama appointed him to run the BLM. He rejoined the consulting group in 2012 after he retired from the BLM, which manages federal lands and is part of the Interior Department.

Ford met Milam in 2011 and represented the Texas investor during the land-purchase process. Ford’s consulting firm was set to receive a $528,000 payment if Milam finalized the transaction, Tuesday’s report said.

But U.S. officials terminated the sale after Milam agreed, as part of a legal settlement with City Hall, to never do business again in Henderson and to pay the city $4.5 million.

His proposed Las Vegas National Sports Complex — comprising an indoor arena and three stadiums south of the M Resort — never materialized. According to Tuesday’s report, he never paid the half-million-dollar fee to Ford, either.

stadium_henderson_rendering02_t653

Artist rendering of the proposed Las Vegas National Sports Complex in Henderson.

Investigators asked Abbey if he benefited from the land sale. According to the report, Abbey said that he hadn’t and that he didn’t receive any payments from the consulting firm as a result of the sale.

“That was one of the issues that I went back and looked at,” Abbey said, according to the report. “I wanted to make sure that when I looked somebody in the eye and said, ‘I have not received a penny from Milam,’ that it was the truth.”

The inspector general’s office said it presented its findings to the U.S. Attorney’s Office, which last year declined to prosecute.

Natalie Collins, spokeswoman for the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the District of Nevada, said Tuesday that agency officials cannot confirm or deny whether someone is being investigated for possible prosecution.

In a phone interview Tuesday, Abbey said he was “shocked” to read the report, which he said was “terribly flawed,” “void of relevant facts” and “heavy on speculation and sensationalism.”

He said his consulting-firm partners landed the Milam contract while he led the BLM — before he returned to the firm — and that he “would not have shared in those proceeds.”

Abbey also said that he was investigated for more than three years, with investigators looking over his bank accounts, reviewing his personal and government email accounts, and interviewing numerous people, including him once.

And yet, he said, they found “absolutely no evidence or information” that could show he was involved in the decisions being made by BLM officials in Nevada in connection with the sale.

“I have no clue how any qualified investigator could reach this conclusion,” he said of the report.

The Henderson City Council in September 2011 approved an initial project agreement with Milam and voted to support the BLM land sale. According to Tuesday’s report, Abbey retired from the BLM on May 31, 2012, and the agency sold the land to Milam days later, on June 4, 2012, for $10.56 million.

Abbey rejoined his consulting firm in June 2012, the firm’s website says.

The inspector general’s report said Abbey’s “involvement in the land sale began early in the process,” as he “conversed or met with Ford on several occasions” before and during the initial sales efforts. According to the report:

• On March 4, 2011, Ford emailed Abbey, saying, “Glad we had time to catch up yesterday in Reno and happy we were able to visit candidly about issues of mutual interest (sic).”

• On March 22, 2011, Ford met with Abbey in Abbey’s BLM office in Washington.

• On March 23, 2011, Ford emailed Abbey at his Interior Department address, telling him to check his outside email account for a message.

• On June 23, 2011, Ford met with Abbey and “an official from a wildlife association” at Abbey’s BLM office in Washington. The report did not name the official or the association.

The BLM published a “notice of realty action” on April 4, 2012, to take public comments on its proposed sale to Milam’s Silver State Land LLC. Ford wrote “at least part” of the notice and “directly contacted” BLM employees “to guide and expedite (its) processing,” the report said.

Abbey also was involved, the report says. On March 7, 2012, an assistant to the BLM’s chief of staff emailed Abbey to tell him the notice had arrived for review. Abbey responded, “Thanks. This land sale is important in bringing jobs to an area of high unemployment. Sooner the better.”

About two weeks later, an attorney from the Interior Department’s legal division, the Office of the Solicitor, reviewed the notice and wrote that the land had “known mineral values.” Under U.S. law, she wrote, when the BLM is selling land, the agency has to determine a property either has no known mineral values or that preserving any existing mineral rights could, for instance, block a development project.

The notice did not address this, so she sent it to a supervisor, an acting branch chief.

On March 23, 2012, Abbey visited the supervisor and asked what was delaying the notice’s publication.

The supervisor later told investigators that it wasn’t unusual for Abbey to visit, “but he found it strange that Abbey came to his office to discuss” a notice of realty action, “as he had never before asked about one.”

On March 27, 2012, Abbey contacted a BLM division chief and asked that she check on the notice. The next day, the report said, Abbey kept trying to learn the notice’s status via email.

During his interview with investigators, Abbey “denied playing a part in the land sale, but when we showed him the series of emails he initiated” about the notice “and his subsequent visit to the branch chief, he said, ‘OK. It sort of reflected I had more interest in this than I thought, huh,’” the report said.

Abbey also said the notice “caught his attention because he did not want it to be ‘sitting in somebody’s in-basket,’” the report added.

Meanwhile, Ford, who spent 25 years with the BLM, had “an unusually high level of access to BLM personnel and processes before and during the Henderson land sale,” the inspector general’s office said,

A realty specialist with BLM’s Nevada state office who was involved in the sale process told investigators that “she gave precedence to Ford’s land applications when he did with business” with the BLM, and that “she had shared draft documents with him” in connection with the Milam sale.

Her actions “appeared to violate federal regulations that prohibit preferential treatment and the improper use of nonpublic information,” the report said.

In a statement provided by the BLM’s office in Reno, agency spokesman Jeff Krauss said the Interior Department takes the report’s findings “very seriously.”

The agency has reviewed the report and “taken the necessary administrative actions,” Krauss said without elaborating.

Read the rest of this story HERE.

12 comments on “Ex-BLM head stood to benefit from sale of Henderson land, watchdog reports

  1. MMS Acting Director Bob Abbey
    http://riskandpolicy.org/mms-acting-director-bob-abbey/
    Administrator Environment, Minerals Management Service, Oil spill, Petroleum in the Environment

    The new Acting Director of the Minerals Management Service (MMS), Bob Abbey, fired an environmental whistleblower, Earle Dixon, in a previous job with BLM. Dixon had complained about lax environmental standards. Here’s a link to the settlement with Dixon. Let’s hope it was an aberration. Regardless, interesting choice in the wake of the current oil spill … .

    Dixon Settlement

    Like

  2. BLM WHISTLEBLOWER WINS APPEAL OVER TOXIC NEVADA MINE
    Labor Department Confirms Retaliatory Firing in Violation of Anti-Pollution Laws
    Posted on Sep 02, 2008
    http://www.peer.org/news/news-releases/blm-whistleblower-wins-appeal-over-toxic-nevada-mine.html

    Earle Dixon, the Project Manager for the Anaconda Mine at Yerington, Nevada, clashed with top Bureau of Land Management (BLM) officials for raising issues that were being ignored because they would drive up clean-up costs and raise political hackles. As a result, BLM removed Dixon from his position in October 2004, one day before his probationary period ended, over objections of his direct supervisors.
    Following a hearing before a federal administrative law judge, Dixon was awarded back pay, $10,000 in moving expenses, attorney fees and costs. That ruling has now been affirmed by the Secretary of Labor’s Administrative Review Board.
    The Anaconda Mine is an abandoned copper mine covering more than 3,600 acres where acid run-off and waste rock containing low levels of uranium, thorium and other toxic metals have been deposited in unlined ponds. The mine has also had a succession of owners, including, most recently, the Atlantic Richfield Company owned by British Petroleum. Dixon pursued persistent clean-up failings, including –

    Radiation readings well above background levels that pose risks to the health of workers onsite;

    Higher than expected contamination of soil, groundwater and drinking water wells; and

    Non-compliance with a number of federal pollution standards, including public and worker exposure to radioactive and toxic metals in air-borne dust.

    Like

  3. stop this corruption by greedy politicians .. putting money in their own pockets at the expense of the wild animals .. slow starvation and needless deaths ..

    Like

  4. Nothing but greed, greed and more greed! Money is the only thing cared about from top to bottom. No one cares about the horses or wildlife unless it benefits them in$$$. So sad our world has come to this!

    Like

  5. Former officials charged with defrauding U.S.
    http://www.eenews.net/stories/1060005745

    Moreover, Larry Ray Denny, 66, who was then deputy director in BLM’s Eastern states office, earned some $67,000 for negotiating a contract for drilling-related service with an American Indian tribe in Montana but failed to disclose those earnings to the federal government, the indictment states.

    The July 18 indictment in the U.S. District Court for the District of Montana charges Denny and 60-year-old John Grimson Lyon, former state director for BLM’s Eastern states, with wire fraud, false claims and theft of government property.
    Denny was also charged with filing false statement about outside income.

    Both have pleaded not guilty and have been released pending an Oct. 27 trial in Great Falls before U.S. District Judge Brian Morris.

    The government is seeking $112,000 in restitution.

    If convicted, Lyon could face 20 years in prison, $250,000 in fines and three years of supervised release, according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Montana.

    Lyon, a scientist and engineer, was appointed state director for Eastern states in June 2011 by former BLM Director Bob Abbey

    Like

Care to make a comment?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s