Horse News

Senate Confirms Bernhardt as Interior Secretary Amid Calls for Investigations Into His Conduct

By Coral Davenport as published on The New York Times

“At least eight senators, all Democrats, and four government ethics watchdog groups have requested that the Interior Department’s inspector general open formal investigations into various aspects of Mr. Bernhardt’s conduct…”

Former energy lobbyist David Bernhardt arrives to testify before a Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee hearing on his nomination of to be Interior secretary, on Capitol Hill in Washington, U.S., March 28, 2019. REUTERS/Yuri Gripas

WASHINGTON — The Senate on Thursday voted to confirm David Bernhardt, a former lobbyist for the oil and agribusiness industries, as secretary of the interior. The confirmation of Mr. Bernhardt to his new post coincided with calls from more than a dozen Democrats and government watchdogs for formal investigations into his past conduct.

Senators voted 56-41, largely along party lines, in favor of Mr. Bernhardt’s confirmation. Three Democrats — Senator Joe Manchin of West Virginia, the senior Democrat on the Senate Energy Committee; Senator Krysten Sinema of Arizona; and Senator Martin Heinrich of New Mexico — supported Mr. Bernhardt, as did one independent, Senator Angus King of Maine.

As interior secretary, Mr. Bernhardt, who has already played a central role in designing many of Mr. Trump’s policies for expanding drilling and mining, will now serve as the nation’s senior steward of its 500 million acres of public land and vast coastal waters.

Mr. Bernhardt was the deputy to Mr. Trump’s first interior secretary, Ryan Zinke, who resigned this year amid allegations of ethical misconduct.

At least eight senators, all Democrats, and four government ethics watchdog groups have requested that the Interior Department’s inspector general open formal investigations into various aspects of Mr. Bernhardt’s conduct. Separately, at least one Democratic senator and one government watchdog group have requested that the United States attorney’s office investigate whether Mr. Bernhardt may have committed civil or criminal violations before he joined the Trump administration.

Mr. Bernhardt has testified to Congress that he has made an effort to be ethical in all his work. “I believe public trust is a public responsibility, and maintaining ethical culture is critical,” he said at his Senate confirmation hearing last month.

He also said that he has sought to strengthen the culture of ethics at the Interior Department, which became notorious for corruption scandals during the George W. Bush administration, when the deputy secretary of the interior, J. Steven Griles, was sentenced to prison for lying to a Senate committee about his ties to the lobbyist Jack Abramoff. At that time, Mr. Bernhardt was the Interior Department’s solicitor.

“I know how important and how devastating it is when folks at the top act in an unethical manner,” he said.

The questions about Mr. Bernhardt’s conduct do not appear to have swayed Republican support for Mr. Trump’s nominee. Republican leaders have praised Mr. Bernhardt’s experience in the Bush administration.

“Mr. Bernhardt has significant private practice experience as well as a past record of service at the Department,” said Senator Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, the Republican leader, in a statement. “Along the way, he’s earned the respect of those who rely on the public lands the Department of the Interior is charged to oversee, from Native American leaders to sportsmen’s groups. He’s been praised as a ‘proven leader’ who ‘acts with integrity’ and has ‘the right approach and skill set.’”

Senator Chuck Schumer of New York, the Democratic leader, said: “It still amazes me. Donald Trump campaigns on cleaning up the swamp and he does exactly the opposite when in office. An oil and gas lobbyist as head of the Department of Interior? My God. That’s an example of the swampiness of Washington if there ever was one. And when are Donald Trump’s supporters going to understand this?”

Environmental groups who opposed Mr. Bernhardt’s confirmation were not surprised that Senator Manchinn — whose state, West Virigina, is rich in coal and who often votes with Republicans on energy and environmental policy matters — supported Mr. Bernhardt. But many environmentalists expressed anger that Senator Heinrich, who has presented himself as an environmental champion, particularly on issues of climate change, backed the confirmation of a former oil lobbyist to oversee public lands.

This week, the Western Values Project, a conservation advocacy organization, ran a television ad campaign in New Mexico urging Senator Heinrich to vote against Mr. Bernhardt.

Senator Heinrich said that, as a lawmaker from a state where roughly one-third of the land is owned and operated by the Interior Department, it was important to him to have a permanent, confirmed secretary at the head of the agency, even if the person in that role was not his first choice.

“I need to be able to pick up the phone and talk to the secretary of interior on a regular basis. I’m not going to be able to get the interior secretary I wanted. We didn’t win in 2016,” he said, referring to the presidential race. “But in New Mexico, I’m going to put my state and protection of public lands in my state first.”

The National Ocean Industries Association, a lobbying organization for offshore drilling companies, including many of Mr. Bernhardt’s former clients, cheered his confirmation. “His unparalleled depth of experience at the department and knowledge of energy and conservation policies will serve our nation’s public lands and resources well,” said the group’s president, Randall Luthi.

Offhore oil companies have been working closely with Mr. Bernhardt over the past several months as he develops the administration’s plan to open up most United States coastal waters to offshore drilling. A draft of that plan was made public last year, and Mr. Bernhardt is expected to put forth a final plan later this year.

Government watchdog groups criticized the ties between Mr. Bernhardt and his former clients. “We know with absolute certainty that Bernhardt will be a horrible secretary, because he had been a catastrophic deputy secretary — eager to do the bidding of his former clients, without regard to the impact on the public lands, endangered species or public health,” said Robert Weissman, president of Public Citizen, which has filed a complaint against Mr. Bernhardt with the Interior Department’s ethics office.

In addition, ethics specialists and Democratic lawmakers have requested that the Interior Department’s inspector general explore the findings of a New York Times investigation in February that revealed that Mr. Bernhardt, while in office, had personally directed a policy to weaken endangered species protections on a California fish, a change that could directly benefit one of his former lobbying clients, the Westlands Water District.

They have also sought an investigation based on a separate Times report detailing previously undisclosed emails indicating that, in the months before he was nominated to office, Mr. Bernhardt continued to lobby for the Westlands Water District even after he filed official papers saying that he had ended his lobbying activities. Federal law requires lobbyists to disclose their activities.

Lawmakers have also sought a formal inquiry into the findings of a report in the Times in March showing that Mr. Bernhardt had intervened to block the release of a scientific report revealing the threat presented by three widely used pesticides to hundreds of endangered species, including the kit fox and the seaside sparrow.

The inspector general’s office has not confirmed that any investigations of Mr. Bernhardt are underway.

6 replies »

  1. What can you say! It’s business as usual. This is a very dangerous appointment. It’s a give our country away to the destroyers of our environments. They just don’t give a damn! Our poor Wild Horses and Burros are hanging on by a thread! Animals once in abundance could show a decline! I have never dispised a person in the White House more than the one there now. If we do not protest in the masses it’s going to be curtains for many species! I was appalled at the finding of those horse skeletons. I hear neive people say the BLM doesn’t ship horses to slaughter. I don’t believe that lie for a jack second! The truth is the American people do not have clue what goes on! The only hope he will tick Cheeto Head off and he’ll force him to resign! That seems to be his style! Hopefully thru court injunctions we can keep him from doing too much damage!


  2. We get what we vote for. Swamp creatures beget more swamp creatures.

    It’s also clear the eastern coast Senators focus mostly on offshore drilling that would affect their communities, not the greater public good for all our states and communities.

    “I would remind all my colleagues on the Atlantic Coast that, again, I asked him to at least commit that he wouldn’t do drilling off the shore of states that didn’t want drilling off their shores. He would not commit to that,” Minority Leader Chuck Schumer said on the floor. “It’s hard to imagine someone whose background is so at odds with the department’s mission than Mr. Bernhardt’s.”
    Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine) told POLITICO she decided to back Bernhardt after receiving written assurances about his plans concerning offshore drilling.

    “I exchanged correspondence with him on the issue that is of most concern to me, which is I do not want to see offshore drilling off the coast of Maine,” she said. “I’m very satisfied with his responses on that.”
    Bernhardt served as the solicitor of Interior during the George W. Bush administration, but subsequent lobbying and legal work on behalf of fossil fuel and water interests have drawn heavy scrutiny. He joined the Trump administration as deputy secretary in August 2017 upon confirmation by the Senate.

    Thursday’s approval by the Senate won’t quell Democratic concerns over Bernhardt’s transparency and conflicts of interest. Multiple lawmakers have demanded an investigation into his role in blocking the release of a study examining a pesticides impact on endangered species.

    Over in the House, Natural Resources Chairman Raúl Grijalva (D-Ariz.) told POLITICO last week he wants Bernhardt to testify “as soon as” possible upon confirmation and last week requested a host of documents from Bernhardt’s former lobbying client about their coordination on endangered species issues.
    House Democrats have also demanded Interior cooperate in an ongoing GAO probe related to that prior client, Westlands Water District, raised questions about compliance with record keeping requirements and sought a copy of the department’s reorganization plan in recent days.”


  3. Recording Reveals Oil Executives Laughing About “Unprecedented Access” to Trump
    During a 2017 meeting, they boast about ties to David Bernhardt, the Interior secretary nominee.
    “Scott Pruitt, he came from Oklahoma, and we have a lot of friends in common and I thought that’s what we were going to talk about, we did that for about three minutes,” Russell said. “And then he started asking very technical questions about methane, about ozone … and if Scott Pruitt thought he was going to go deep nerd …”

    The audience began laughing.

    “And what was really great is there was about four or five EPA staffers there, who were all like, ‘Write that down, write that down,’ all the way through this,” Russell continued. “And when we left, I said that was just our overview.”

    The audience laughed again.

    “So it’s really a new world for us and very, very helpful.”

    Naatz predicted Bernhardt would actually run the department while Zinke would play a ceremonial role.

    “What secretaries of Interior do is go out to Yellowstone, go out to Tetons … have big vision for what they’re going to do,” he said. “David is going to be the COO. David’s going to move the pieces. David’s going to be part of that, and we know him well.”



  4. As the saying goes..”it’s an ill wind that blows no good”. Much of what has happened has flushed the hidden culprits out into the open.
    NOW…the legislators who voted to confirm him need to go…and work for the private/corporate industries to which they have sold themselves.


  5. IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA UTE INDIAN TRIBE OF THE UINTAH ) AND OURAY INDIAN RESERVATION ) 898 S. 7500 E. ) Fort Duchesne, Utah 84026 ) ) Plaintiff, ) ) v. ) Civil Action No. _____________ ) UNITED STATES OF AMERICA ) 950 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W. ) Washington, D.C. 20004 ) ) UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT ) OF THE INTERIOR ) 1849 C. Street, N.W. ) Washington, D.C. 20240 ) ) RYAN ZINKE, Secretary of the Interior ) Department of Interior ) 1849 C Street, N.W. ) Washington, D.C. 20240 ) ) And ) ) DAVID BERNHARDT, Deputy Secretary ) of the Interior ) Department of Interior ) 1849 C Street, N.W. ) Washington, D.C. 20240 ) ) Defendants. ) COMPLAINT Plaintiff, UTE INDIAN TRIBE OF THE UINTAH AND OURAY INDIAN RESERVATION, for its Complaint against the above-named Defendants, alleges as follows:

    7. David Bernhardt is the Deputy Secretary of the Interior. As Deputy Secretary, David Bernhardt is vested with numerous trust, fiduciary and other legal duties owed to the Tribe under various treaties, executive orders, congressional acts, judicial decrees, and express and implied contracts. He is sued in his official capacity. 8. The United States, the Department of the Interior, Ryan Zinke, and David Bernhardt are collectively referred to herein as “Defendants” or “Federal Defendants.”

    Dated this 8th day of March, 2018.

    Click to access 1-complaint.pdf


    • My goodness – surprise surprise! Our “government” continues to screw over Indians in every way possible. I never heard what happened with the attempt by the Reservation in, I believe North Dakota(?) that was trying to put 911 home addresses on every home on that reservation so they could VOTE! I’m positive there were many many instances of preventing votes last election – for instance, the one in Dodge City that created difficulty for Mexican immigrants from voting. And this is supposed to be the “Land of the Free”!
      Sorry – politics. Have to stop watching the news shows I guess.


Care to make a comment?

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.